What are the 3 types of SEO, and which should you start with?

TL;DR The 3 types of SEO are technical, on-page and off-page, and you start with technical. They're not three options but three floors: a badly indexed site wastes its content, and vague content wastes your links.
Colorful raised letters S, E, and O spelling SEO on a white background
Colorful raised letters S, E, and O spelling SEO on a white background. Photo by Merakist on Unsplash
“A journey of a thousand miles begins with a single step.”
— Laozi, Tao Te Ching

Mid-September, a few days after launching the new version of my site, I opened Search Console. The German pages I had just rewritten for Upper Valais were in the sitemap all right, but the status was blunt: "Discovered – currently not indexed". Fifteen years in the trade, and Google was treating me like a total stranger.

Their old versions, meanwhile, were still online, still indexed, and still holding their entire ranking history. Six pairs of pages were fighting over the same searches, and more than 17% of my impressions were scattered across several addresses for one and the same question. The content was better and the site was faster, but Google kept showing the old one.

That episode sums up the problem with the three types of SEO perfectly. They're often presented as a menu: a bit of technical, a bit of content, a few links. In reality, they're the floors of the same building. Put a beautiful floor on a shaky base and it won't bring you anything.

Why SEO gets sold in three packages that never talk to each other

Let's start with the definitions, because they're simple:

  • Technical SEO: what makes sure robots can reach your pages, understand them and index them (speed, redirects, canonical tags, language versions);
  • On-page SEO: what each page says and how it says it (headings, copy, structure, data);
  • Off-page SEO: everything the rest of the web says about you (inbound links, mentions of your name, client reviews, your Google Business Profile).

Three families, three angles, and most guides stop there, as if the list were enough to know what to do with it.

Three quotes, no running order

The problem isn't the split; it's what the market does with it: three separate services, often three providers, each with their own dashboard. A backlink package here, a technical audit there, ten blog posts a month somewhere else.

Each one optimizes their own floor and measures their own indicators. Nobody is responsible for the whole, and nobody tells you where to start, because the honest answer doesn't always suit the person selling it.

The weakest link decides for the other two

An inbound link to a page that isn't indexed passes on almost nothing. A perfect text published on a duplicate page competes with its twin. A flawless technical structure around vague content produces a very tidy site that nobody finds.

The three types of SEO don't add up, they multiply. If there's a zero anywhere in the chain, the rest of the investment is working for nothing.

Start with technical SEO so Google can read everything

First floor: making sure every page you want in the results is reachable, indexable and unique. It's the least visible of the three, and yet it's the one that decides whether the work on the other two even gets counted.

One page, one address: redirect the rest

On my own site, the cause was mundane: a URL migration that was only half finished. The new translated URLs existed, but the old ones hadn't been redirected. The fix is one line per page, a 301 redirect, which works like a "moved permanently" sign that passes the old address's history on to the new one.

That's why this work gets prepared before any website redesign , not after. My redirects file has 166 rules since the move from Webflow to Astro, and each one exists because an old URL still had value to pass on.

The ceiling of technical SEO

Let's be honest: technical SEO has a ceiling. At the end of August, an audit of my site came out at 8.3 out of 10 (markup, hreflang and redirects included), and my commercial queries in Valais were still on page two or further. On a site of around a hundred pages, crawl budget simply isn't an issue.

Once the base is clean, every extra franc spent on technical work brings back less and less. It's a prerequisite, not a lever. A third technical audit in a row mostly buys you peace of mind.

Move on to on-page SEO: one intent, one page that answers it

Second floor: checking that every important search has a page that answers it, and only one. That's where most of the ranking happens, because Google doesn't compare your site to the question, it compares one specific page to it.

Give every search its page

In mid-September, my site had no French page indexed for SEO. For "seo valais", Google was hesitating between the homepage, a service page and even the contact page, which has no chance of satisfying someone looking for a consultant. The pricing pages, meanwhile, showed zero impressions, because the homepage was taking nearly two thirds of them.

The fix isn't a trick: take the pricing module off the homepage, build the missing page, merge the Brig and Naters pages (two towns two kilometers apart that were competing for the same intent). Fewer pages, but each one has a reason to exist that Google can identify.

Write headings that actually say something

The rest of on-page is more classic, and just as often neglected. My case studies used generic headings like "Context", "Challenge" and "Solution", and close to 150 gallery images had no alt text. A robot reading "Solution" learns nothing about what was solved, or for whom.

The same logic applies to answer engines: a page that clearly explains who does what, where and for whom is the one that ends up cited by ChatGPT or Perplexity . Schema.org markup in JSON-LD adds a machine-readable layer, but it never rescues a text that says nothing.

Finish with off-page: what the rest of the web says about you

Third floor: the signals that come from outside. Google says it plainly in its documentation: it uses links as a relevance signal and to discover new pages. Mentions of your name, your reviews and your business profile play a similar role, especially in local search.

Stabilize your addresses before the links

If off-page comes last, it's not because it matters less. It's because a link points to one precise address: if that address changes, disappears or exists twice, the link's value gets diluted. Chasing links before your URLs are stable is like printing business cards before you've picked your phone number.

The same goes for your identity. For my own brand query, Google was serving sixteen different addresses on the site. A consistent name, a stable address and official profiles that link to each other (LinkedIn, GitHub or the Webflow certified partner directory) let the engines understand they're dealing with one entity, not sixteen pages to choose between.

What no provider can buy for you

It's also the floor I have the least control over, for you as much as for me. Links bought in bulk break Google's rules and sooner or later cost more than they bring in. The good signals come from a client citing your work, a partner referencing you, a local paper writing about your project.

They take months, they can't be ordered, and that's exactly why they carry weight. A clean site that's clear about what it sells doesn't guarantee them, but it makes sure each one really counts on the day it arrives.

My own link profile is a good example. Most of it comes from footer credits on sites I've built, including those of several clients in Sierre such as Sierretakeuil and the Ski Club Sierre, plus local.ch, the directory of independent professionals and the Webflow partner directory. What was missing was a page that tells the story of the work: Sierretakeuil and Baobab Energy now publish a news item describing what we built together, and that kind of source, more than a hundredth identical credit, is what an engine reads as a recommendation.

SEO doesn't have three types, it has a building order

The question of the three types of SEO has a textbook answer: technical, on-page, off-page. The useful question is a different one: which of those floors is holding your site back today? Working on the second floor while the first one leaks is like repainting a façade on a damp wall.

Diagnosis before budget

It's the order I follow on my own site and for my clients, and it's the heart of any SEO strategy that lasts: a diagnosis first, then the floor that's blocking, then the next one. The budget doesn't get split into three equal parts; it goes where the weak link is.

That discipline has a visible cost: it delays the spectacular moves, the article series and the link campaigns in favor of fixes nobody notices. But it's the only way to know, three months later, what actually moved your rankings.

Ready to find out which floor your site is losing visibility on?

Your site doesn't need all three types of SEO at once. It needs someone to find the floor that's holding the other two back, and to fix it before investing anywhere else. Quite often, the answer is already sitting in your Search Console, and it costs less than you'd fear.

👉 Want to know which of the three floors is holding your site back today? Get in touch